I used to own the Yaesu FT-2800 (its predecessor), and I currently own an Icom IC-2200H.
Both radios are fully capable 2m mobiles. I think it will come down to personal preference on how they feel to operate and which one you can get for the best price.
I only got rid of the FT-2800 because I wanted to pick up a 2m/70cm mobile. If money had permitted, I would still own it.
The menus on both are pretty typical for modern mobiles and neither is a particular problem once you have sat down and read the manual.
The IC-2200H has the option to fit a D-Star board if that floats your boat...